What Happens Next? How to Build a Plot That Keeps Readers Turning Pages

You have your characters.

You know where they live. You know what they want. You may know their childhood, their greatest fear, their favorite food, and exactly what they would order at a coffee shop.

Then you sit down to write the next chapter and...

Nothing.

Your character is standing in the kitchen drinking coffee.

Again.

You stare at the screen and ask the question nearly every writer eventually asks:

What happens next?

Welcome to Plot & Story Structure Month at Boshers Publishing.

This month, we're going to look at how writers can take characters and ideas and turn them into stories that actually move.

And we're starting with one deceptively simple question:

What Does Your Character Want?

Before deciding what happens next, figure out what your character is trying to accomplish.

Every strong plot needs movement, and desire creates movement.

Your character might want to:

Save their marriage.

Find a missing person.

Escape their hometown.

Protect their child.

Solve a murder.

Win someone's love.

Build a new life.

Hide a secret.

Prove someone wrong.

Survive.

The goal doesn't have to involve saving the world.

It simply has to matter deeply to the character.

Because once your character wants something, you have somewhere to take the story.

But there's a catch.

Don't let them have it.

At least not yet.

Conflict Is the Engine of Your Story

Imagine this story:

A woman wants to open a bakery.

She finds the perfect building.

She gets the loan.

Her family supports her.

The renovations go beautifully.

Customers love the bakery.

She becomes successful.

The end.

That's lovely for her.

It's not particularly exciting for us.

Now change a few things.

She wants to open a bakery using recipes passed down from her grandmother.

But she can't get financing.

Then someone else buys the building she wanted.

Her sister discovers that one of their grandmother's recipes may have actually belonged to someone else.

And just as she finally finds another location, a successful bakery opens two doors down.

Now we have a story.

Why?

Something is standing between the character and what she wants.

That's conflict.

When You're Stuck, Don't Ask What's Interesting

This is one of my favorite questions for writers who don't know what should happen next.

Don't ask:

What would be interesting here?

Ask:

What would make things harder for my character?

That question changes everything.

Your detective finally finds a witness?

The witness disappears.

Your character finally gets the job?

Her new boss is the person she hoped never to see again.

Two characters finally admit they're in love?

One discovers the other has been hiding something.

Your protagonist finally thinks they're safe?

They're not.

You aren't throwing random disasters into the story just to create drama.

You're creating obstacles connected to what the character wants.

That's the difference.

Raise the Stakes

Conflict gives your character a problem.

Stakes tell readers why the problem matters.

Ask yourself:

What happens if my character fails?

Maybe they lose money.

That's a stake.

But what if losing the money means losing the family home?

Now the consequence is more personal.

What if losing the family home means breaking a promise they made to their dying father?

Now you've added emotion.

The strongest stakes aren't necessarily the biggest.

They're the ones that matter most to that particular character.

Use the "What If?" Question

Two tiny words can rescue a stalled plot:

What if?

What if the person she trusts is lying?

What if he arrives too late?

What if the evidence points to the wrong person?

What if she gets exactly what she wanted and discovers she doesn't want it anymore?

What if the villain knows something the protagonist doesn't?

What if the secret comes out at the worst possible moment?

What if winning means losing something else?

Don't judge the ideas immediately.

Write them down.

Some will be ridiculous.

Good.

Sometimes the ridiculous idea sitting at number twelve leads you to the brilliant idea sitting at number thirteen.

Give Your Character Choices

Plot isn't simply a collection of things that happen to your protagonist.

Your character should make decisions that affect what happens next.

That's important.

Instead of:

Something terrible happens.

Then something else terrible happens.

Then another terrible thing happens.

Try:

Something happens.

Your character makes a choice.

That choice creates a consequence.

The consequence forces another choice.

That choice creates another problem.

Now your protagonist isn't being dragged through the plot.

They're helping create it.

And that's usually far more interesting.

Make Things Worse, But Make Them Matter

There's a temptation when learning about conflict to start throwing everything at your protagonist.

Car accident!

Lost job!

Tornado!

Secret twin!

Suddenly there's a bear!

🐻

Technically, things are happening.

But that doesn't necessarily mean you have a stronger plot.

Conflict should feel connected to the story.

If your character's greatest fear is losing custody of her child, threaten her ability to remain in that child's life.

If your protagonist desperately wants his father's approval, force him to choose between earning that approval and doing what he believes is right.

The best obstacles don't simply make life harder.

They force characters to reveal who they are.

Your Middle Isn't Supposed to Be Filler

Many writers know how their story begins.

They often know how it ends.

Then somewhere around the middle, everybody starts wandering around having conversations while the writer quietly panics.

The middle should be where things change.

Goals become harder to reach.

Relationships shift.

Information is revealed.

Plans fail.

Consequences grow.

Characters make mistakes.

The reader's understanding of the situation changes.

If your middle feels slow, ask:

What has changed since the beginning?

If the answer is "not much," you've probably found the problem.

Build Toward Something

Your conflict should eventually lead somewhere.

As the story progresses, choices should become harder and consequences should become greater until your character reaches a moment they can no longer avoid.

That's your climax.

The climax isn't simply the loudest scene in the book.

It's the moment when the central conflict demands an answer.

Your protagonist has spent the story running.

Now they have to turn around.

They've been hiding the truth.

Now they have to tell it.

They've been trying to save everyone.

Now they have to decide who they can actually save.

Everything you've built should begin converging.

That's when readers feel that wonderful sense that the story has been leading them somewhere all along.

So... What Happens Next?

The next time you're staring at your manuscript wondering where your story should go, try this:

What does my character want?

What's standing in the way?

What happens if they fail?

What choice could they make right now?

What consequence would that choice create?

And finally:

How can I make this harder without making it random?

You may discover that you don't need a brand-new plot idea.

You simply need to put more pressure on the one you already have.

Because a plot isn't just a sequence of events.

It's a chain of wants, obstacles, choices, and consequences.

And somewhere inside that chain is your answer to:

What happens next?

✍️ Today's Writing Challenge

Open your manuscript and find the scene you're currently working on.

Write down:

My character wants: __________

But: __________

So they decide to: __________

Which causes: __________

Now look at that last answer.

There's a very good chance you've just discovered your next scene.

Need Help With Your Story?

If your plot has wandered off without leaving a forwarding address, you don't have to untangle it alone.

Boshers Publishing Author Advisory is currently FREE.

Bring your questions about plotting, characters, dialogue, writing, publishing, or figuring out what comes next.

Visit BoshersPublishing.com to learn more.

Boshers Publishing

Read. Write. Imagine.